Wed. Jun 19th, 2024

I have mentioned that the B.C. Treaty Process is always controversial because there is always a significant difference between what Indigenous Peoples see as their “Original Title” to the land and its resources and the Canadian and B.C. legal notion of ‘Aboriginal Title. This issue prevents further negotiation from continuing.

In this article, I will explain Aboriginal Tittle in Canadian law, and an Indigenous perspective and why reconciling the Canadian legal understanding of Aboriginal title with Indigenous knowledge remains a significant challenge.

What Is “Aboriginal Title” In Canadian Law

Under the Canadian law, the Aboriginal title is sui generis, or unique collective right to the use of and jurisdiction over a group’s ancestral territories. The land title originates in a First Nation community’s occupation of its ancestral lands before the European assertion of sovereignty.

As such, Aboriginal Title and Rights are separate from rights afforded to Canadian citizens under the common law. In that regard, the Aboriginal Title may not be sold or purchased by individuals; it may only be voluntarily surrendered to the Crown by a First Nation community through treaty agreements. Some First Nations do not agree with these definitions, as they consider Canadian purposes of limiting the scope of Aboriginal Title, making it easier to extinguish.

In B.C., this narrow perspective proved especially controversial. Some claimed that the colony of British Columbia was not subject to the Royal Proclamation. The British Columbian government argued that Aboriginal Title had been extinguished by colonial legislation before the province entered the Canadian Confederation. As a result, no treaties for the surrender of the Aboriginal Title were completed. The Aboriginal Title does not negate the Crown’s sovereign title to the land. Instead, Aboriginal title is a “burden” — a legal acknowledgment of that title — upon the Crown’s underlying Title. The governance of those areas where Aboriginal Title is recognized, and the implications for private property rights, have not yet been thoroughly defined.

First Nation Perspectives of Aboriginal Tittle and Land

First Nation peoples across Canada and B.C. have maintained a solid connection to the land. Even though there is vast cultural variation between First Nations, most groups held similar beliefs that governed their relationship with and responsibility to the ground.

Most First Nation communities did not believe that pieces of land could or should be owned by particular individuals. Humans, along with all other living beings, belonged to the ground. The land provided for humanity, and in turn, society bore a responsibility to respect and care for it. Many First Nation peoples understand this as a reciprocal relationship with the land because they do not own the lands.

Aboriginal Tittle: A Great Challenge

Reconciling the legal understanding of Aboriginal title with First Nation understanding remains a significant challenge. For example, the First Nations believe that Aboriginal Title cannot be surrendered but only shared. The concept of private property ownership is an idea introduced by the European settlers.

The idea that Aboriginal title would be a proprietary right to the land stands in contrast to Indigenous concepts of land ownership. Thus, Canadian sovereignty over lands is not dependent upon an agreement with First Nations concerning Aboriginal title, and reconciling the Canadian legal understanding of Aboriginal title with Indigenous knowledge remains a significant challenge.

Bibliography

Crowe, Keith. “Comprehensive Land Claims: Modern Treaties”. The Canadian Encyclopedia, 11 July 2019, Historica Canada. https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/comprehensive-land-claims-modern-treaties. Accessed 23 November 2021.

Dyck, Lillian E., et al. A Commitment Worth Preserving: Reviving the British Columbia Treaty Process. Canada Senate, Ottawa, Ont., 2012.

McNeil, Kent. “The Meaning of Aboriginal Title.” In Michael Asch, ed.  Aboriginal and Treaty Rights in Canada: Essays on Law, Equality, and Respect for Difference. Vancouver: UBC Press, 1997. 135-154.

Woolford, Andrew. “Negotiating Affirmative Repair: Symbolic Violence in the British Columbia Treaty Process.” Canadian Journal of Sociology, vol. 29, no. 1, 2004, pp. 111.

Green, Arthur, et al. British Columbia in a Global Context. Geography Open Textbook Collective, 2014.

Hanson, Eric. “Aboriginal Title.” Indigenous Foundations. First Nations and Indigenous Studies UBC, 2009. Accessed 23 November 2021.

This is an opinion article; the views expressed by me. Follow him on Twitter: @hkpltw And @Terry_Terence97

36 thoughts on “Why Reconciling Legal Understanding of Aboriginal Title with Indigenous Understanding Is a Significant Challenge? (BC First nations Treaty Discussion)”
  1. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!

  2. I am an investor of gate io, I have consulted a lot of information, I hope to upgrade my investment strategy with a new model. Your article creation ideas have given me a lot of inspiration, but I still have some doubts. I wonder if you can help me? Thanks.

  3. I’m just writing to make you understand of the useful discovery my wife’s girl developed studying your site. She realized plenty of pieces, which include what it’s like to possess a great giving mood to make many people without hassle have an understanding of several grueling subject matter. You truly surpassed readers’ expectations. Thanks for providing the precious, trustworthy, edifying and even unique guidance on this topic to Evelyn.

  4. I simply wanted to thank you very much once again. I am not sure the things I might have carried out without those tips documented by you concerning this topic. It was before a terrifying scenario for me, but taking a look at a new skilled fashion you resolved that forced me to cry with gladness. Now i’m thankful for the support and even expect you realize what an amazing job you are putting in training some other people all through your website. I’m certain you have never met any of us.

  5. I enjoy you because of every one of your labor on this web page. Betty loves getting into internet research and it is simple to grasp why. My partner and i learn all concerning the lively mode you convey very helpful guides by means of your web blog and in addition attract response from the others on this area and our favorite girl is always starting to learn so much. Have fun with the rest of the year. You are conducting a very good job.

  6. I intended to put you this very little note to give thanks again for the amazing techniques you have provided in this article. It is so strangely open-handed of people like you in giving openly just what a lot of people might have distributed as an electronic book to end up making some dough for their own end, most notably considering that you could possibly have done it if you ever considered necessary. The creative ideas likewise acted to provide a fantastic way to understand that some people have a similar dream similar to my very own to see much more in regard to this problem. I am sure there are a lot more fun instances in the future for individuals who find out your site.

  7. I’m writing to let you understand of the terrific discovery our girl went through using your site. She mastered lots of details, most notably what it is like to possess an incredible coaching heart to get others very easily grasp some impossible matters. You truly exceeded my expectations. I appreciate you for producing these useful, safe, educational and also unique tips about this topic to Ethel.

  8. I must show some appreciation to this writer for bailing me out of this dilemma. After researching throughout the internet and coming across techniques which were not helpful, I believed my life was done. Being alive without the presence of strategies to the problems you’ve fixed by means of the guideline is a crucial case, as well as those that could have adversely damaged my career if I hadn’t come across the website. Your actual talents and kindness in maneuvering all the details was useful. I’m not sure what I would have done if I hadn’t come across such a stuff like this. It’s possible to at this time relish my future. Thanks so much for your reliable and result oriented help. I will not hesitate to propose your blog post to any individual who ought to have counselling about this problem.

  9. I wanted to create you that little bit of word to finally thank you so much over again on your amazing tricks you’ve shown above. This is remarkably generous of you to give unreservedly exactly what a lot of people would have offered for sale for an electronic book to generate some bucks for their own end, most importantly since you might have tried it in case you wanted. The basics likewise worked to be the great way to fully grasp that some people have the identical desire just like my own to figure out whole lot more in respect of this matter. I am sure there are a lot more fun instances ahead for many who scan your blog post.

  10. I precisely wanted to say thanks once again. I do not know the things I would’ve implemented without these tips contributed by you on my question. This has been an absolute difficult setting for me, nevertheless encountering your expert tactic you solved it took me to jump with happiness. I’m just grateful for your work and thus believe you really know what an amazing job you have been doing instructing people with the aid of your web page. More than likely you haven’t encountered any of us.

  11. I am writing to make you understand of the brilliant experience my friend’s girl gained browsing yuor web blog. She figured out lots of pieces, which included what it is like to have an incredible teaching style to make many others smoothly learn specific impossible subject areas. You undoubtedly did more than our desires. I appreciate you for presenting these valuable, trustworthy, informative and even unique thoughts on that topic to Lizeth.

  12. My wife and i felt really lucky Ervin could finish up his analysis through the precious recommendations he was given through the blog. It’s not at all simplistic to simply find yourself giving away guides that many others may have been making money from. Therefore we keep in mind we have got you to give thanks to for this. All of the illustrations you’ve made, the simple site navigation, the friendships you will make it easier to create – it’s got many terrific, and it’s really helping our son and our family understand the subject matter is awesome, which is certainly pretty pressing. Thanks for all!

  13. I precisely wished to thank you so much once again. I’m not certain what I could possibly have made to happen without the advice contributed by you relating to such a topic. Entirely was a terrifying concern for me, however , observing the well-written approach you managed it took me to jump over delight. I am just happier for the information and believe you realize what an amazing job you were putting in educating men and women via your webblog. Most probably you’ve never encountered any of us.

  14. I want to express my admiration for your generosity in support of individuals who absolutely need guidance on your question. Your personal dedication to passing the solution along came to be rather insightful and has usually enabled some individuals like me to get to their endeavors. The warm and helpful instruction implies much to me and still more to my office workers. Regards; from each one of us.

  15. I simply had to thank you so much once more. I am not sure the things I would’ve used without the actual concepts revealed by you about that area of interest. It seemed to be a very difficult matter for me personally, nevertheless taking note of your expert technique you dealt with the issue forced me to jump with fulfillment. Now i’m happier for your information and believe you really know what an amazing job you happen to be doing educating others via a web site. Probably you’ve never got to know any of us.

  16. Needed to create you the tiny observation to help thank you the moment again about the remarkable things you’ve provided on this website. It is so pretty open-handed of people like you to deliver freely exactly what some people could possibly have marketed as an e book to help with making some money on their own, particularly since you could possibly have done it in case you considered necessary. These tactics in addition worked to become easy way to be sure that the rest have the identical interest just like my very own to realize very much more related to this condition. I think there are lots of more enjoyable instances ahead for those who read carefully your blog.

  17. I together with my friends have been looking through the excellent tips located on your site while then I got an awful suspicion I had not expressed respect to the web blog owner for those techniques. All the guys ended up absolutely happy to see them and have in effect simply been taking pleasure in these things. We appreciate you getting so accommodating as well as for considering these kinds of extraordinary areas most people are really desperate to be informed on. My very own sincere regret for not saying thanks to sooner.

  18. My spouse and i have been now relieved when Edward managed to finish up his inquiry from the ideas he had through the weblog. It’s not at all simplistic just to continually be giving for free guides others might have been selling. And we also fully understand we now have the blog owner to thank because of that. All the illustrations you have made, the easy site menu, the friendships you will give support to foster – it is all fabulous, and it’s making our son in addition to our family recognize that this article is excellent, and that’s unbelievably mandatory. Thank you for all!

  19. I wish to express thanks to the writer just for bailing me out of such a difficulty. Right after browsing throughout the world-wide-web and finding methods which are not productive, I figured my life was done. Living without the solutions to the issues you have resolved as a result of your main article content is a serious case, and those which might have negatively affected my career if I had not noticed your blog. Your main capability and kindness in taking care of a lot of stuff was crucial. I’m not sure what I would’ve done if I hadn’t come across such a thing like this. I am able to at this point relish my future. Thanks a lot so much for this expert and results-oriented guide. I won’t be reluctant to refer your blog post to any person who ought to have care about this problem.

  20. Thanks a lot for providing individuals with a very wonderful possiblity to discover important secrets from this blog. It really is so fantastic and as well , full of amusement for me personally and my office colleagues to visit the blog at a minimum three times a week to study the fresh guidance you have. And of course, I’m just actually happy with your extraordinary solutions served by you. Selected 4 areas in this post are undoubtedly the most efficient we’ve ever had.

  21. I want to express my thanks to you for rescuing me from this crisis. Right after looking through the world-wide-web and getting ways that were not beneficial, I believed my life was well over. Being alive devoid of the solutions to the issues you have fixed by way of your blog post is a serious case, and the ones that could have negatively damaged my career if I had not come across your web page. That know-how and kindness in maneuvering all areas was important. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not come across such a step like this. I am able to at this time relish my future. Thanks for your time so much for your professional and results-oriented guide. I will not think twice to endorse your blog post to anyone who should get tips on this situation.

  22. Thanks a lot for giving everyone an extremely pleasant opportunity to read critical reviews from this website. It is always so excellent and also jam-packed with amusement for me personally and my office acquaintances to visit the blog really three times in 7 days to read the newest things you have got. Of course, we are usually amazed considering the beautiful methods served by you. Certain 4 tips in this post are without a doubt the most beneficial we have all ever had.

  23. I wish to show some appreciation to the writer just for rescuing me from this particular condition. Because of looking out through the world-wide-web and getting solutions that were not powerful, I was thinking my entire life was well over. Existing devoid of the approaches to the difficulties you have sorted out through this article is a serious case, as well as ones that would have in a wrong way affected my career if I had not discovered your website. Your personal understanding and kindness in maneuvering all things was tremendous. I am not sure what I would’ve done if I hadn’t encountered such a solution like this. I’m able to at this point look ahead to my future. Thanks a lot very much for the specialized and effective guide. I will not be reluctant to refer your blog to anybody who wants and needs support on this subject matter.

  24. I am glad for writing to let you understand what a beneficial discovery my child undergone using your web page. She realized a lot of things, which include how it is like to have a great giving heart to have many more without problems know precisely several specialized matters. You really surpassed our expectations. Thank you for giving those warm and friendly, dependable, explanatory and easy tips about that topic to Gloria.

  25. I intended to compose you one very little remark so as to give many thanks once again for your stunning suggestions you have discussed at this time. This has been simply particularly open-handed with you to provide freely all many people could possibly have sold as an electronic book to get some cash on their own, and in particular considering the fact that you might well have tried it in the event you wanted. The techniques likewise served to be a fantastic way to recognize that someone else have similar dreams much like mine to know whole lot more concerning this problem. I am sure there are lots of more enjoyable moments ahead for many who look into your site.

  26. I needed to write you that little word to finally give many thanks once again for your personal amazing basics you’ve provided on this site. This has been quite unbelievably open-handed with you in giving without restraint just what a number of us would have offered for an ebook to help make some money for their own end, primarily given that you might have done it in the event you considered necessary. These good tips also acted to be the fantastic way to fully grasp many people have the identical desire just like mine to know more with regard to this matter. I’m sure there are lots of more enjoyable sessions ahead for individuals who browse through your site.

  27. I not to mention my friends happened to be checking the nice strategies from your web blog while unexpectedly developed an awful suspicion I had not thanked the website owner for those strategies. All the men happened to be totally happy to read them and now have very much been tapping into these things. Appreciate your truly being really thoughtful and also for selecting certain wonderful useful guides most people are really desperate to discover. My personal sincere regret for not expressing appreciation to you sooner.

  28. I precisely had to thank you so much once more. I’m not certain what I would have taken care of in the absence of the strategies revealed by you about such area of interest. It previously was a real horrifying case in my opinion, nevertheless encountering the very skilled avenue you managed the issue made me to leap over gladness. I will be happier for this help as well as pray you are aware of a powerful job that you’re carrying out educating many people all through a site. More than likely you have never come across all of us.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *